SPYOPS.PL

SpyOps.pl › Pop culture vs reality › “Munich” (2005)

Pop culture vs reality○ Disputed

“Munich” (2005)

Steven Spielberg’s film about Israel’s response to the attack on Olympic athletes in Munich in 1972. It is based on a book whose credibility has long been questioned, and it leaves out the Lillehammer affair, which in reality halted the campaign.1,2,3

The real case

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesAfter Black September’s attack on Israeli athletes at the 1972 Munich Olympics, Mossad launched a campaign – dubbed “Wrath of God” by the media – to track down and kill those it held responsible.2

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesIn July 1973 in Lillehammer, Norway, an Israeli team misidentified its target: instead of Black September chief Ali Hassan Salameh it killed a Moroccan waiter, Ahmed Bouchiki. Salameh was killed by a car bomb in Beirut in 1979.2,3

What the film gets right

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesAccording to the History News Network, the film accurately shows that Prime Minister Golda Meir authorised the operation, as well as the joint Mossad and army operation against Black September figures in Beirut in 1973.4

What was added or changed

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesAccording to former Mossad officers who appeared in the documentary “Munich: Mossad’s Revenge”, the campaign did not fall apart because the agents lost their nerve – as the film suggests – but after the disaster at Lillehammer, which the film does not mention.2

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesThe plot comes from the book “Vengeance”, based on the account of a man presented as “Avner”. The press linked him to Yuval Aviv; a former Mossad agent called the book “nonsense”, although he did not dispute the mission itself. The composition and methods of the teams are also most likely shown inaccurately.1,4

What remains for the viewer to judge

According to media and secondary accounts · not confirmed by official sourcesSpielberg did not claim to recreate the events literally, and the film is above all about the moral questions of revenge. As a source of knowledge about the campaign itself, however, it is weak: it relies on a disputed account and leaves out its greatest failure.1,4

Sources

  1. American Film Institute – AFI Catalog, Munich (2005)
  2. „The Guardian” (przedruk: „Mail & Guardian”), Munich: Mossad breaks cover, 26.01.2006
  3. „Mail & Guardian”, Mad about Munich, 20.01.2006
  4. History News Network (George Washington University), How Accurate Is Munich?

Checked: 15 November 2026

A TheScience.fm podcast

Na celowniku

Conversations on security with recognised guests (in Polish).

Listen →